Compare Electric Vehicles
Compare price, battery, charging, ownership cost, running cost, features and performance.
MG Motor
Comet EV₹7.80 - 10.07L
Ex-showroom · Delhi
Est. on-road: ₹8.12L
- Range
- 230 km
- Battery
- 17.3 kWh
- Fast Charge
- 55 min
Tata Motors
Punch EV₹9.69 - 12.59L
Ex-showroom · Delhi
Est. on-road: ₹10.07L
- Range
- 468 km
- Battery
- 40 kWh
- Fast Charge
- 26 min
Quick Verdict
Your instant takeaway, before the detailed comparison below.
Best Value
Punch EV
Longest Range
Punch EV
Fastest Charging
Punch EV
Lowest Running Cost
Comet EV
Editor's Pick
Punch EV
Quick Verdict
- Best ValuePunch EV
- Longest RangePunch EV
- Fastest ChargingPunch EV
- Lowest Running CostComet EV
- Editor's PickPunch EV
Overview
Key numbers at a glance.
Battery
- MG Motor17.3 kWh (gross)
- Tata Motors40 kWh (gross)
Range
- MG Motor230 km
- Tata Motors468 km
Power
- MG MotorNot available
- Tata MotorsNot available
Torque
- MG Motor110 Nm (at motor)
- Tata MotorsNot available
Top Speed
- MG Motor100 km/h
- Tata Motors150 km/h
Acceleration
- MG Motor14.2s (0-100)
- Tata Motors9s (0-100)
Charging Time
- MG Motor55 min (10-80%)
- Tata Motors26 min (10-80%)
Efficiency
- MG Motor7.5 kWh/100km
- Tata Motors8.5 kWh/100km
Price Comparison
On-road price estimate for Delhi, Delhi. Change city to see how it affects the breakdown.
| Component | Comet EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Ex-showroom Price | ₹7,80,000 | ₹9,69,000 |
| Registration / RTO | ₹0 | ₹0 |
| Road Tax | ₹0 | ₹0 |
| Insurance (est.) | ₹23,400 | ₹29,070 |
| Other Charges (est.) | ₹8,500 | ₹8,500 |
| Total On-Road Price | ₹8,11,900 | ₹10,06,570 |
Estimated for Delhi, Delhi — confirm with your dealer. Ex-showroom price, registration, road tax, and insurance all vary by city.
EMI Calculator
Loan amount: ₹6,49,520
Monthly EMI
₹13,641
Total Interest
₹1,68,948
Total Cost
₹9,80,848
Battery
| Specification | Comet EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Battery Capacity | 17.3 kWh (gross) | 40 kWh (gross) |
| Range | 230 km | 468 km |
Charging
| Specification | Comet EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| DC Fast Charging (10-80%) | 55 min | 26 min(winner) |
| AC Home Charging (full) | 7 hr | 5.3 hr(winner) |
| Charging Port | Not available | CCS2 |
Performance
| Specification | Comet EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Torque | 110 Nm (at motor) | Not available |
| 0-100 km/h | 14.2s | 9s(winner) |
| Top Speed | 100 km/h | 150 km/h(winner) |
| Regenerative Braking | Yes | Yes |
| Drive Layout | RWD | FWD |
Ownership Cost
Estimated cost of owning each vehicle — some categories (maintenance, resale) have no reliable published data yet and are shown honestly rather than guessed.
| Component | Comet EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Charging Cost (est.) | ₹8,665 | ₹9,846 |
| Annual Insurance (est.) | ₹23,400 | ₹29,070 |
| Road Tax / Registration, Delhi (est.) | ₹0 | ₹0 |
| Annual Maintenance | Not available | Not available |
| Service Cost | Not available | Not available |
| Battery Replacement Estimate | Not available | Not available |
| Battery Warranty | Not available | Not available |
| Resale Value Estimate | Not available | Not available |
| 5-Year Cost (on-road + charging + insurance est.) | ₹9,48,825 | ₹11,72,081 |
Running Cost
Adjust the inputs below to estimate your own monthly and yearly running cost.
Charging Cost Calculator
Estimated — assumes ₹15/unit for public charging and ₹105/₹92 per litre for petrol/diesel.
Monthly Cost
₹902
Yearly Cost
₹10,829
Savings vs Petrol / yr
₹89,971
Savings vs Diesel / yr
₹62,771
Dimensions
| Specification | Comet EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 2974 mm | 3880 mm |
| Width | 1505 mm | 1742 mm |
| Height | 1640 mm | 1622 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2010 mm | 2445 mm |
| Ground Clearance | Not available | 195 mm |
| Boot Space | Not available | 366 L |
| Tyre Size | 145/70 R12 | Not available |
Safety
| Specification | Comet EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Airbags | 2 | Not available |
Features
Warranty
Colours
Available colour options — swatches only, no manufacturer imagery.
Comet EV
Candy White
Punch EV
Supernova Copper
Pros & Cons
Pros are each model's own highlights; cons are computed, factual losses against the other compared vehicles.
Comet EV
Pros
- Tiny turning radius
- Twin 10.25-inch screens
- Dual-tone interior themes
Cons
- Lower range than the Punch EV
- Lower battery than the Punch EV
- Lower top speed than the Punch EV
- Higher acceleration than the Punch EV
Punch EV
Pros
- 468 km ARAI range on the 40kWh pack
- Battery-as-a-Service purchase option
- Lifetime battery warranty on the 40kWh pack
Cons
- Higher ex-showroom (starting) than the Comet EV
Expert Verdict
A neutral summary generated from the categories each vehicle actually leads on above — not editorial opinion.
Comet EV
The Comet EV leads on ex-showroom (starting). It also has the lowest starting price among the vehicles compared. Best suited for buyers who prioritize ex-showroom (starting) over the alternatives here.
Punch EV
The Punch EV leads on range, battery, top speed. Best suited for buyers who prioritize range over the alternatives here.
Ratings
Scored relative to the vehicles in this comparison (0-10) — not an absolute or editorial rating.
Comet EV
Overall
Performance
Charging
Comfort
Not enough data
Technology
Not enough data
Safety
Not enough data
Value
Ownership
Punch EV
Overall
Performance
Charging
Comfort
Not enough data
Technology
Not enough data
Safety
Not enough data
Value
Ownership
Owner Reviews
No ratings yet — be the first to review the Comet EV.
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your experience with the Comet EV.
Frequently Asked Questions
Comet EV
Punch EV
Quick Verdict
- Best ValuePunch EV
- Longest RangePunch EV
- Fastest ChargingPunch EV
- Lowest Running CostComet EV
- Editor's PickPunch EV
Quick Verdict
- Best ValuePunch EV
- Longest RangePunch EV
- Fastest ChargingPunch EV
- Lowest Running CostComet EV
- Editor's PickPunch EV
Related News
Launches, software updates and coverage for the vehicles compared here.
No news yet
Coverage of the Comet EV and Punch EV will appear here once published.
Keep Exploring
Similar Vehicles
Explore Brands
Similar Comparisons
Which one should you buy?
Comet EV
A solid all-round choice among those compared.
Punch EV